Your question has been sent.
Expect an answer!
9 Market St, Potsdam, NY 13676-2808, Potsdam
6:30 am
6:30 am
6:30 am
6:30 am
It does not appear that the Bagerly delivers, however you can order in advance online
I’ve been there three times. Great food and workers. Highly recommend the buffalo chicken bagel! And the one with Nutella bacon and Brie (I forgot what it’s called)
Use to be the place to be after the bars closed as they stayed open late on I think Friday and Saturday nights...would be PACKED 1-2AM. Graduated in 2014 so I have no clue how it is now but was always the spot after a long night of drinking. Pizza bagels were AMAZING. Everyone use to freak out in excitement over the pickles! LOL
Quite good bagels, "made fresh every day", with quite a few sandwiches on them as well. They sell "second-day" bagels at a pretty reasonable price, but the sandwiches are pretty pricey and will take a couple minutes. The restaurant setup is rather sparse and spacious; probably a good place to spend an hour or two working, but too small to invite a large group.
Husband came into get us bagels ... he orders me chicken salad bagel on wheat .... they threw cold chicken salad on a rock hard bagel no cheese melted on top ...one bagel didn't even have salad on part of it . This isn't the first time of disappointment here last time we came in we ordered a cookie got charged for it and never was put in our bag .
The first photo is a pizza bagel the second is the gobble Turkey russian and provolone on a onion bagel
My food was great but my wife's food was made incorrectly. We were in a hurry so we didn't say anything and just ate it and left.
A Northern NY staple. Best place to have breakfast, hangover or not! Plus super nice staff and good prices!
Food was great! However there is a young lady that was working this morning...or not working as she says but was working/cooking...could hand me a piece of foil! Extremely rude! Never even an appology.
The most creative options I've seen on a restaurant menu. Don't go in there expecting a NY bagel though
Food and coffee is great but week have to wait and Some times there is no seating.
Our family stopped here for breakfast while camping in the area. It was highly recommend on TripAdvisor, and it definitely lived up to the reviews. Great menu, great service. We enjoyed it so much that we came back a second time before heading home. This is not your run of the mill "DD" bagel, these are unique, delicious food pairings for people who enjoy fresh natural food instead of fast food fare.
Always good for a quick bite downtown!
Very good specialty bagels.
Pesto chicken bagel was next level.
You would get five starts if you EVER HAD ANY OF THE BAGELS I WANTED. Every single time I come here, no matter the time of the day it is, you don't have any garlic or everything left. Most of the time My only choice is poppy or wheat. If u run out every single day, make more the next time!!! I would understand if it was an occasional thing, but it never fails, its every time. And for the price you charge, I ought to be able to have the bagel I want!!!. today I was here before 1pm, and already u were out of every good bagel. Its so discouraging. Makes me not want to come here anymore.😡
Great bagels. It was one of my favorite places to eat when I was in college.
Perfect bagel .
Pretty good food. Took a little while for food to arrive, so if you're in a rush this is not ideal.
Great sandwiches, service is quick. Good coffee, plenty of bottled drinks in selection.
Good signature bagels. Student friendly
Great service and excellent breakfast sandwiches.
Excellent food, dont bother trying to get delivery if you are not using a card though. You cannot place an order online without one, and the woman I just spoke to there, yes, working there speaking to me on the phone.... said she didnt know if I could order food over the phone and pay cash..... queue 10 seconds of awkward silence.... so I said thanks anyway, she apologized and hung up.
I always like the bagerly but they always forget something on my bagel. I paid extra for an avocado and didn’t get it on my sandwich and didn’t notice until I got home.
Great Food !
Very good
$10 for a bagel sandwich! Turkey, lettuce, onions, and cheese. Was not made to order! Could have bought a sub and fed 2 for less $.
A decent spot to get a sandwich on a bagel, or a bagel in general, which they make in house. Probably the best spot in the area for bagel/sandwich. They don't have everything like a Subway or anything like that but I'm sure if demand for a certain meat, cheese, or topping goes up they would consider getting it. Have a bunch of different varieties of bagels. I usually get the buffalo chicken or chicken bacon ranch on a everything wheat bagel.
A wide variety of bagel options and toppings. Great place to stop for breakfast.
Beautiful serene place win indoor and outdoor seating.Friendly faces to welcome and serve you, and the chai milkshake seems to be the fountain of youth😋
Great for Breakfast or Lunch!
Good food, but kinda pricey. Coffee is amazing. They have cold brew as well as hot. Quality of food ingredients is good. Fresh, authentic bagels cooked everyday onsite.
The locks with capers and red onion on a salt bagel with Northern Delight cream is awesome!
My sinful side loves this place. Great bagal sandwiches and Park Bro. coffee.
Really great food for casual meals
A nice variety of bagels and interesting sandwich options make the bagelry a delightful lunch/dinner option when you're looking for something just a little bit different.
Perhaps my favourite eatery in all of Potsdam, at least it's the one I miss most and would go back to visit! Great bagel sandwhiches such as the pulled pork or reuben, really enjoyed!
Place has been around since 1982, NYC style bagels. Good place for a quick, healthy bite!
Just not the wow factor it used to have. Egg salad used to be delicious!
Great food. Just dont work there
Great bagel sandwiches! COVID rules followed. Felt safe.
Love "The Gobble" on an Onion Bagel ... but I do miss the late nights.
I love The Bagelry - I ate there all the time in college and now that I moved away I crave a Buffalo Chicken Sandwich with ranch at least once a month.Whether it be the Canton or Potsdam location they do a great job of staying consistent and their bagels are SO. FRESH. IN. THE. MORNING.Best time to go is before 9am!Go there and order anything, it's all good :)
A fun stop when I am passing through Potsdam. I usually buy a bag of bagels to take home. Don't think they have ever all made it. Just to hard to resist a soft chewy bagel. They're very good about packing the sweet and smelly bagels in separate bags.
This place has become a fast food franchise. Used to get a meal for your money, now they raised prices for a snack. Asked for a Toasted bagel, then add the chicken salad and melt the cheese. I get a raw bagel with a portion meant for a single slice with melted cheese. Used to be a Need to stop off every time we visit old stomping grounds. NEVER again!
I can't express how much you need to go to this place if you are in potsdam! Try everything, I haven't found anything I don't like yet.. plus you can buy cups of their spreads to enjoy their bagels at home. 😊
AWSOME!!
I have never been in the restaurant, but they deliver and I order from here a lot. The menu is diverse, ordering from the website is very easy, and delivery is really fast. The only thing close to a problem I have had is their pickle policy. Do sandwiches come with them? You can add an extra pickle, but when I select that, I still only get one. If I don't select a pickle option, sometimes I get one, sometimes I don't get any. It is such a small, weird issue that I wouldn't knock a star off for it, but it just confuses me.
Amazing lox and beagles. The smoked salmon was a bit pricey, but the potion was pretty large. I took half of the lox off to have tomorrow. The service is great!
The bagels were good, the interior could be a little more cozy though
Fresh baked bagels, local coffee, and a wide variety of specials (all centered around the mighty bagel) make this cafe a sweet destination for any but those with the strictest dietary restrictions.My one gripe with them is that they've raised their prices around 4-5 times since I moved up here and haven't seemed to do anything beyond renovating their bathroom area once over the past 5 years. Paying $10+ for a bagel with toppings just seems over the top with where it's located.
Your question has been sent.
Expect an answer!
Thank!
Your review has been submitted.
Thank you for being with us!
We will call you back!